Gothos

I’ve started outlining a one-day, introductory GIS practicum / workshop that I hope to offer in the coming academic year. One of the primary examples I want to use in the workshop is site selection for a retail store, and I thought it would be great to use a subway layer as part of the exercise. But alas, I searched high and low for a layer late last year (for a site selection project) and couldn’t find a publicly available one. I had purchased some proprietary layers, but really don’t want to use them for this workshop because I want to be able to freely distribute all of the materials to anyone; the layer I purchased is also outdated now because the MTA cut many services (including two subway lines) last month.

But thanks to Steve Romalewski at the CUNY Mapping Service, there’s now an alternative! Steve’s work is a HUGE contribution to the GIS community in New York and fills a glaring hole in the city’s collection of freely available GIS data. The MTA does host a data feed service (based on the General Transit Feed Specification created by Google) where it provides the geography of all its transit services, among other things. Steve downloaded and processed this raw data and turned it into shapefiles. He quickly discovered that it required a fair amount of scrubbing to be usable, and he’s cleaned it up and documented the entire process in great detail in several posts on his blog (Spatiality). Links to download individual shapefiles are available at the bottom of each post, following his discussion of issues and methodology for each set of layers. The CUNY Center for Urban Research has created an index page with each post, which you can access here.

In addition, he’s created a lyr file for the subway lines in order to symbolize them correctly by color and a separate mxd file for labels. While the shapefiles represent where the lines are, there are some problems representing them as they appear cartographically on the MTA’s subway maps. Many lines, including some with different colors, share the same trunk line. For example the A and C trains (blue lines) share the same trunk with the B and D trains (orange lines) along 8th Ave from 59th St to 145th St. Depending on how you sort your symbol categories, you’ll only see one color (and line) depending on which one you have on top. Steve points out two ways for solving this issue – you can edit the geography and offset one of the lines, which is tedious and creates problems as you change scale (he has some great screen shots that depict this). If you’re using ArcGIS, he shows off some cartographic tools that you can use to offest lines by prioritizing values in the attribute table. This is more ideal, as it gives the illusion that the lines are side by side cartographically while keeping the geometry of the shapefile intact.

So if you’re using ArcGIS you’ll be good to go. I’ve downloaded the files to play around with, but as I’m at home and using QGIS I had some more work to do, since lyr and mxd files are proprietary ESRI formats that the open source packages can’t handle. I’ve assigned the appropriate colors to each subway line and saved them a QGIS style file (.qml), which you can import in the symbology window to quickly and easily get the right colors (which I plucked from the MTA’s website). I’ve also saved the RGB and hex values for each line in a text file, if you’re using some other GIS software and need to input them manually. As far as I know there isn’t an easy way to circumvent the shared-line subway problem if you’re using QGIS (see screenshot below), so you’d have your work cut out for you if you want to faithfully represent the lines the way they appear on the MTA maps. But if you’re using the layers for analysis (which is what I’ll be doing) or you don’t need to emulate “the” subway map in exact detail, it shouldn’t matter.

• NYC subway QGIS style file (.qml)
• NYC subway colors RGB and Hex (.txt)

NYC subway layers from CUNY Mapping Service in QGIS

Footnote – for anyone who is interested, the proprietary data that I purchase for the college is from a company called Halcrow. The entire NYC transportation package costs $465. It includes NYC subways and buses (lines and stations for each, along with ridership statistics from 2008 and a historical bus stops layer from 1998), LIRR and Metro North (lines and stations), but also includes the PATH train, freight lines, and truck routes.

I haven’t been posting regularly as I’ve been swamped this semester – but now that it’s coming to an end I should be able to crank out a post or two each month.

I recently saw a message on Maps-L about a new GIS data source, Natural Earth, and just got around to taking a look at it. It’s run by a volunteer organization dedicated to providing free, integrated, public domain map layers for producing high-quality maps at small scales. They have a pretty comprehensive website that includes a blog, feature list, contributor information, and details on how to volunteer.

Natural Earth provides smooth, generalized vector and raster layers at three scales: 1:10m, 1:50m, and 1:110m. See my screen shot of the Delmarva peninsula to see the distinctions (beige area is 110m, red line is 50m, and blue line is 10m).

Having a choice of scales with vector and raster data layers from the same source is a huge plus (many other country-level boundary files available on the web are detailed and suitable for large scale maps, but look messy when you zoom out to a smaller scale). Natural Earth also provide outlines for land and water (including legal water boundaries for all the Pacific islands), hydrographic features generalized to the different scales, ice shelves, urban areas, and several lat/long grid line layers.

For country boundaries they’ve gotten around the tangled issue of country definitions by providing different layers for different definitions, so you can choose the one that’s most appropriate – sovereign states (so, Greenland would be part of the Denmark polygon, Alaska and Puerto Rico part of the US, and French Guiana part of France), countries (Greenland separate from the Denmark polygon, Puerto Rico separate from the US, Alaska part of the US, and French Guiana part of France), and subunits (each place its own polygon). As you move down this hierarchy, places are linked back to their whole (so there are fields in the subunit file that list which country and sovereign state it’s part of).

At this point subdivisions (states / provinces) are only provided for the US and Canada. They do provide some descriptive metadata for each layer on the website, but the metadata doesn’t follow any standardized format for geographic data. The biggest missing link is unique identifiers – none of the countries have ISO or FIPS codes, so there aren’t any fields to join attribute data to for thematic mapping (except country name, which never works smoothly given the amount of variation with names).

Overall this looks like a great resource. Vector data is in shapefile format, raster data is in tiff, and everything is defined as simple WGS 84, so these files should work with almost any GIS package, ready to go.

Here’s my last chance to squeeze in a post before the month is over. There have been a lot of changes and updates with some key data sites lately. Here’s a summary:

• The homepage for gdata, which provides global GIS data that was created as part of UC Berkeley’s Biogeomancer project, has moved to the DIVA-GIS website. DIVA-GIS is a free GIS software project designed specifically for biology and ecology applications, with support from UC Berkeley as well as several other research institutions and independent contributors. It looks like the old download interface has been incorporated into the DIVA-GIS page.
• The US Census Bureau has recently released its latest iteration of the TIGER shapefiles, the 2009 TIGER/Line Shapefiles. Since they seem to be making annual updates, which has involved changing the URLs around, it may be better to link to their main TIGER shapefile page where you can get to the latest and previous versions of the files.
• The bureau has released its latest American Community Survey (ACS) data: 2008 annual estimates for geographic areas with 65,000 plus people, and three year 2006-2008 estimates for geographic areas with 20,000 plus people. Available through the American Factfinder.
• Over the summer, UM Information Studies student Clint Newsom and I created a 2005-2007 PUMA-level New York Metropolitan ACS Geodatabase (NYMAG). It’s available for download on the new Baruch Geoportal, which was re-launched as a public website this past September. It’s a personal geodatabase in Microsoft Access format, so it can only be directly used with ArcGIS. I plan on creating the 2006-2008 version sometime between January and March 2010, and hope to release an Access and SQLite version, as the latest development versions of QGIS now offer direct support for SQlite geodatabases in the Spatialite format (which is awesome!).
• While it’s not a source for GIS data or attribute tables, it’s still worth mentioning that the CIA World Factbook completely revised their website this past summer. The previous web versions of the factbook took their design cues from the old paper copies of the report. The CIA revamped the entire site and apparently will be using a model of continuous rather than annual updates. It’s a great site for getting country profiles – another good option is the UN World Statistics Pocketbook, which is part of the UNdata page.

I recently went through my pages of suggested links for data and resources to update and clean them up. I’ve included many of the cool resources I’ve discovered since I started writing this blog, which ended up in individual posts but not in these pages. I went over the resources page in particular, to try and classify the reference materials, tools, and software into useful categories rather than just having one large blob of stuff.

I’ve stumbled across a few good sites for GIS data lately. Check these out:

UNSDI-NCO: The United Nations Spatial Data Infrastructure site, maintained by the Netherlands Coordination Office. They have many global datasets as well as country-specific ones, often for developing countries where data is hard to come by. Includes boundaries, roads, infrastructure, and natural features. Click on the Datasets link under the Categories menu to see the list, then click on the feature of you choice. You’ll have to scroll through the metadata to the Distribution Info element to get to a download link. Not all of the datasets are available for public download.

gData: This site is housed at Berkeley as part of the Biogeomancer Project, whose goal is to share data on biodiversity. You can download boundaries, hydrography, infrastructure, topography, and climate data in vector and raster formats for any country in the world. The data is aggregated, and in some cases improved, from many public sources. Administrative boundaries include 1st, 2nd, and often 3rd level divisions. A great, comprehensive source.

CEGRP: China Earthquake Geosptial Research Portal, housed at Harvard. The goal of the site is to gather and distribute geospatial data in response to the earthquake that hit Sichuan China in May 2008. Vector and raster layers for all of China and for this particular region where the earthquake hit.

AIMS: Afghanistan Information Management Services. A non-profit group located in Afghanistan that has created and maintains a geospatial infrastructure to support the government. Vector datasets for the entire country and the city of Kabul are available for download. They also offer a number of static pdf maps.